What Is an Interlocutory Petition in Trademark Law?
An interlocutory petition is an application before the Court seeking temporary relief pending the completion of the proceedings. This type of judicial procedure plays a vital role in protecting trademark owners’ rights before the Court makes the final decision.
If a third party starts functioning under a name or logo that leads to confusion with the existing trademark, a person can ask for an interim injunction.
An interlocutory petition is a plea which does not solve the controversy completely but seeks the aid of the Judiciary in connection with the issue on which an urgent response from the authority is required.
Why Trademark Owners File Interlocutory Applications?
Trademark owners may apply for provisional orders to prevent any further infringement.
These orders can be particularly useful if there is potential for confusion amongst consumers, to cause damage to the brand's reputation or for the sale of counterfeit goods.
If no prompt interim protection is provided, the damage will increase before the final ruling is made.
Legal Basis: Trade Marks Act and Order 39 CPC
The basis for obtaining interim relief in a trademark case can be found in;
Section 135 of the Trade Marks Act 1999, allowing a court to make orders for injunctions and interim relief under passing off or infringement. This also provides for ex parte injunctions and orders for preservation of evidence and discovery.
Order XXXIX is represented by Rules 1 and 2 of CPC, which provide temporary injunctions to prevent specified injury or continuous violations of legal rights.
Order XXXIX also contains Rule 3, which obliges a court to state the reasons for granting an injunction in the absence of the opposite party.
Section 151 of CPC confirms the innate power of courts in issuing orders that are essential for administering justice and preventing the abuse of procedures.
Also, Section 134 of the Trade Marks Act stipulates the powers of courts regarding the hearing of cases on passing off and infringement issues.
Types of Interim Relief Available
Depending on the circumstances, a court can impose:
1. A specific temporary injunction, which prohibits a defendant from using a conflicting/deceptive trademark.
2. An ex parte injunction, which does not involve the hearing of the other side and takes effect immediately.
3. Directions in interim, which comprise the parties’ conduct during the process of the action.
4. The preservation of the objects of the infringement, including goods, documents, etc.
5. Discovery of documents, which establishes the need for the production of documents related to the case.
6. Orders related to assets preventing the party from disposing of or otherwise handling the assets in cases established in Section 135(2)(c).
When Should You File an Interlocutory Petition? If the legal or commercial interests of a trademark owner are threatened, the option of filing an interlocutory application is available.
Typical situations include:
- Rival use of the same or confusingly similar brand name.
- Distribution of fake goods under the registered trademark.
- Unauthorised exploitation of an existing logo or label.
- False advertising, which creates consumer confusion.
- Infringement still in progress despite the issuance of a legal notice.
In order to have judicial protection granted, an interlocutory application must contain specific supporting evidence.
Essential Conditions: Prima Facie Case, Balance of Convenience, Irreparable Harm
Generally,y three factors are considered by judicial courts while granting a preliminary injunction.
Prima Facie Case – It requires the applicant to establish a valid case to be heard. For example, in a trademark case, it requires the applicant to establish that they have ownership/ rights to the trademark.
Balance of Convenience – This considers the expected inconvenience that would be faced by the parties. If the harm caused to the applicant due to the rejection of the injunction is more than the harm caused to the respondent due to granting of the injunction, then the applicant's request for relief is justified.
Irreparable Harm – The applicant must establish that denying them interim relief will cause damages that can't be compensated.
The Supreme Court has outlined the principles of obtaining a temporary injunction in the case of Dalpat Kumar vs. Prahlad Singh (1992).
Documents Required to File the Petition
Generally, the following will be included:
A copy of the main Trademark Infringement/passing off claim.
Trademark Registration Certificate if relevant.
Trademark Application Information if the Trademark is awaiting approval.
Evidence of previous use of the brand.
Screenshots, images or advertisements, etc., showing the alleged infringement.
Invoices, sales records, and the marketing documents.
Legal notices and other important correspondence.
Supportive affidavits and other documents relied upon.
The documents should prove the rights of the applicant and the alleged activities of the defendant and the urgency of the relief being asked for.
Step-by-Step Filing Process
The basic steps to follow in the process are given below.
Ensure that you collect the required evidence proving that the trademark has been used without permission.
Prepare the necessary paperwork for starting the proceedings, specifying the facts and legal grounds for your claim regarding the infringement and passing off.
Prepare an interim application setting out what you are trying to achieve on an interim basis and why.
Provide evidence in support of the claim with documents as well as an affidavit.
Bring an action in a court of law with jurisdiction under the law in question.
Attend the hearing presenting the claims supporting the demand for interim relief.
Carry out the directions given by the court in respect of notices, service, and procedures.
Ex Parte Injunction vs. Notice to the Other Party
An ex parte order is given without giving notice to the opposite party. It may be allowed if it can be shown that by providing the defendant with notice, it would cause some detriment or could do some irreparable harm.
The reasons for allowing this relief must be given under Order XXXIX Rule 3 of the CPC. Notice of the petition, accompanying documents and order must be properly served on the opposing party.
In most cases where an application is made for an interim injunction, notice will be given to the defendant to allow them to reply.
Role of Courts in Granting Interim Orders
The courts will look into whether there is any proof, legal rights, a pressing need and also the potential harm to the two parties. The courts will exercise their judicial discretion.
In addition, the courts have the power to change, adjust or revoke any interim orders based on the current trends and any evidence presented in court.
Common Mistakes That Lead to Rejection
Common mistakes include:
- Not proving ownership or enforceable trademarks.
- Failing to provide clear proof of the infringement.
- Not showing enough urgency or irreparable harm.
- Making unintelligent or overly broad requests.
- Withholding important information from the court.
- Not following procedures.
- Not taking action even though evidence of infringement is available.
Conclusion
An interlocutory petition serves as a significant legal mechanism allowing parties to secure provisional relief within trademark infringement proceedings. Such instruments permit brand proprietors to address urgent matters regarding infringements, counterfeits, and unauthorised applications swiftly.
However, in order to obtain an interim injunction, there must be strong evidence and some criteria must also be met. If acted quickly, the correct documents are gathered, and good legal documentation is created, then the chances of success will increase.
FAQs
What is an interlocutory petition?
This is an application made during the course of a trademark suit to obtain interim relief such as an injunction.
When can it be filed by the trademark owner?
This can be filed by the trademark owner if there is an immediate threat to their interest due to unauthorised use, counterfeiting or deceptive similarities.
What relief can the courts provide?
An injunction (temporary or ex parte), discovery, preservation of evidence, and certain directions in relation to assets under Section 135 of the Trademarks Act.
What is the difference between temporary injunction and permanent injunction?
A temporary injunction is issued while the proceedings are ongoing. A permanent injunction is issued in the decree.
What needs to be proven to obtain interim relief?
Generally, proof of a prima facie case, balance of convenience, and irreparable damage will need to be shown.
What documents are needed to file the application?
The applicant will need to provide documents such as details of the trademark registration, evidence of use, screenshots of infringement, invoices, a copy of the principal plaint, supporting affidavit, and any other evidence.
7. How long until we can obtain interim relief?
This depends on the circumstances. Applications made in urgent circumstances may be dealt with quickly. Ex parte applications may also be made.
Can we appeal an interlocutory order?
In most cases, yes. Orders granting, refusing or amending an injunction (Order XXXIX Rules 1 and 2) can be appealed (Order XLIII Rule 1(r) CPC.
Need Help With an Interlocutory Petition?
Don't file a procedural petition without first identifying the exact issue, applicable rule, supporting evidence, and relief required.
Get professional assistance from eStartIndia for trademark proceedings and related documentation.
Contact eStartIndia today to discuss your trademark matter and get assistance with the appropriate filing process.


Leave a Comment
Previous Comments